Trivium – ‘CROWN IN THE GRAVE’

By Ian Kenworthy

The problem with being a metal band – the problem with being Trivium – is that you can’t do anything right. The stereotypical metal fan, the stereotypical Trivium fan, seems to hate everything they do. If it’s not ‘Ascendency’ it’s not good, or it’s not their old stuff, or they’ve sold out. Hence, every album is promoted as a comeback or a return to their roots. How many times do you have to call it a comeback before anyone admits they never went away? Really, their output has been pretty consistent. You can point to a dip with the decidedly iffy ‘Vengeance Falls’ in the centre, but even then they were working with an interesting producer, they were trying something new. The promotion for ‘Crown In The Grave’ leans into this idea – they want you to think it’s a comeback. The reason lies with Matthew K. Heafy.

Heafy’s social media feed is fascinating. Recent posts have seen him covered in tattoos, working out like a professional athlete and talking about his mental health, his bad mental health. This has been a feature of all the album’s promotional interview, they make it sound like this record’s existence is a miracle. While making last year’s EP ‘Struck Dead’ he decided the band’s dynamics were broken and quit. After some serious soul searching, he decided to return. Listening to ‘Crown In The Grave’ you can tell. Whatever he found in the depths of his soul was worth sharing.

The opening instrumental ‘Jorogumo’ immediately sets the tone. In a nod to Heafy’s heritage woodwind instruments and distant drums create a Japanese flavour. It’s uneasy and becomes more intense until the whole thing blows apart, leading into the title track. That’s where you hear it, the discomfort and intensity. ‘Crown In The Grave’ is built around weird guitar riff full of string bends, it sounds demonic. That sound that comes to define the whole record. It’s amongst the band’s heaviest and most technical albums, and certainly the most abrasive. There’s a tone to the vocals and guitars that feel like walking through desert on a windy day. It’s not a bad thing either because it captures the mood, the hostility, that drove Heafy to quit. It’s like they’re exorcising those demons.

Each of the band’s records fits into one of two boxes, either heavy and technical or more melodic. This is the former, similar to 2017’s ‘The Sin And The Sentence’. While that record often felt bogged down by its meandering songs here they are flighty, focused and persistently inspired. There is a reason for this; the riffs coil around each other, the guitars play at a counterpoint and yet there is a clear focus. It’s all in service of a story. Indeed, although it shares the style of 2021’s ‘In The Court Of The Dragon’ there is an indefinable zest to the songwriting that you only notice by direct comparison.

The record’s background provides a fascinating insight into band dynamics. A record is not the result of just one person but that person’s input vastly shapes how the band functions together and thus the resulting music. You can hear this in the way the songs combine a technical showcase with a more structured song style, how they delight in pauses and breaks, and how these choices infuse the whole record with power and tension. This results in the crushing heaviness of ‘Devour Your Dreams’, the way ‘Lie Of It All’ feels like a rock ballad but is fractured by some truly intense metal flourishes like blast-beats and a slick guitar riff. You can also hear it in how ‘The Haunting Never Ends’ has its dreams of being a punk song shredded by the duelling solos. It’s also notable how often slick basslines make their mark, particularly during the middle section of ‘The Paradise Of Sinners’.

Heafy’s vocals combine singing, growling, and his signature intense yell, but there’s more flavour this time, he has never sounded better. Each phrase has differing tones and inflections which gives every line character. You can hear it clearly on the atmospheric vocal on ‘Dead Inside Of Me’, especially during the breakdown section, or on ‘The Haunting Never Ends’ where it sounds like he’s pleading for release. It’s an impressive piece of work that really captures the difficulties that inspired the record. His yells are impressive and powerful which really stands out on ‘The Terror’ where he bellows the song’s title over the slick guitar solos, then drags out a scream long after the music has ended. In the lyrics he repeatedly references the difficulties that led to the record’s creation. It’s clearly the basis of ‘The Agony’ and ‘The Haunting Never Ends’ which features the refrain “The feelings of guilt keep returning,” so although it’s effective, it’s not exactly subtle.

The record’s greatest strength is its songwriting, which is somewhat masked by its heaviness. Each song features a careful mix of melody so they always feels distinctive and often genuinely inspired. Notably ‘Blackout The Dawn’ is underscored by an acoustic guitar and a ladder-like riff that lends it a constant sense of momentum. On ‘The Dawn That Never Comes’ they explore a mood and style which is particularly immersive. Similarly, on the delightfully unhinged ‘The Paradise Of Sinners’ a slight change of tone implies they they’re not taking themselves too seriously. It seems fun without breaking the record’s coherence. In doing so it avoids what we’ll call the ‘Bullet For My Valentine trap’ where a lack of self-awareness tips their work into camp. Basically, this is a record that knows exactly what it’s aiming to achieve and it does so with style.

At this point in their career you’d expect Trivium to be burnt out. They used it to their advantage. By reworking what makes them great they’ve created something uncomfortable, revitalised and urgent. This is one of their strongest records period. Staking their claim to be one of the greatest metal bands on ‘Crown In The Gave’, Trivium exorcise their demons with style, panache and legendary songs.

IAN KENWORTHY

Three more album reviews for you

RXPTRS– ‘TALES OF ILL REPUTE’

LIVE: Papa Roach + Landmvrks @ The O2

Reclusé - ‘The World Can’t Take Much More’