Punktastic.com
Wecome Guest, please login or register.
Sponsorship Message
News Forums PT Recordings Bands Reviews

Submit news | Band of the Week |Reading Festival Live| PT RSS:RSS Feed

How Soon Is Now? A Tribute To The Smiths, Various Artists
If the stage wasn't already set for Morrisey's return to the limelight, the number of bands openly name-checking Mozzer and The Smiths certainly gave the seminal artist a massive publicity boost. If it wasn't Brand New and Taking Back Sunday openly paying homage, you would see many of the bands on this collection referencing them. I've never been a huge fan of The Smiths if I'm being completely honest. At 24 my musical education started after The Smiths were in their heyday, so perhaps had I grown up and lived through their golden years it would all be a different story.

As a result I can probably look at 'How Soon Is Now?' without the rose-tinted glasses of bias of many reviews I've seen. These songs were never going to compare to the classic original versions - when has a sequel or cover ever bettered the original in any type of media? The 12 tracks on offer here do vary greatly in quality. Instruction provide one of the highlights with a storming cover of 'Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me', while Garrison's 'Panic' stays pretty true to the original. Lomax and Walter Walter don't stray too far from their originals either.

The most 'controversial' track is Hundred Reason's version of the album title-track. Some have proclaimed it as great, others as a shocking take on the track. I'm indifferent - at least it's a decent stab at putting their own take on the song, rather than mimicking Morrisey and ultimately failing. Unlike My Awesome Compilation, who's cover of 'There Is A Light That Never Goes Out' which is disjointed and too jaunty. They're good friends of mine, but that doesn't excuse the fact this is by no means their best work.

'How Soon Is Now?' was always going to court controversy because it could be seen to be cashing in on a popular trend. I disagree with those sentiments and Smiths fans will probably seek this out to see how other bands have attempted to cover their heroes. Like any compilation, there are hits and there are misses - and this is reasonably evenly balanced.

Released on Sorepoint

Paul

starstarstarstarstar

» Want to review this record? Click here to leave your comments

Posted by Paul
10:01PM, 1st October 2004
237 Views

Tell a Friend about this item


Options:
Reviews Index «
Back a Page «
 Subscribe to PT Mail

Menu
Releases
Reviews
Interviews
Gig Calendar
Punktastic TV
Columns
FAQ
About/Contact
Calendar

TV

Shop

Reviews
Big Bold Letters
Cruiserweight
12th Oct 2008, Paul
image
Fiction Fever, The Bigger Lights
That's What She Said, The Friday...
Solemn Boyz EP, Paper The Operator
Deliverance, Quietdrive
You Are My Sunshine, copeland
Nibiru, Lavondyss
Life Is Not A Waiting Room, Senses...
Oh Deer EP, Firebrand Boy
Done, Apologies I Have None

Gig Reviews
Innerpartysystem
London Camden Underworld
9th Oct 2008, Paul
image

Interviews
Houston Calls

11th Oct 2008, Paul
image

Competitions
image

Today's Gigs
There are no gigs today!

Sponsorship Message

Content © Punktastic 2008 - Design & Scripting by Robert Bethell

PT Recordings PT Recordings News News Reviews Reviews Bands Bands Forums Forums