Punktastic.com
Wecome Guest, please login or register.
Sponsorship Message
News Forums PT Recordings Bands Reviews

Submit news | Band of the Week |Reading Festival Live| PT RSS:RSS Feed

Sometimes you just have to be cruel to be kind. No offence intended, but unless you point out fundamental problems as a reviewer, band's won't improve. Whether said band's opt to listen to advice from someone stupid like me is another entity altogether, but here's my twopenneth. Hailing from Kent, PoS play what is fast becoming THE genre - sod black t-shirted clad "hardcore" (sed loosely) bands, now it's the turn of those who tinker keys and splatter samples all over their sound. PoS do plenty of both, although their scattergun effect really doesn't do either of the two songs here any justice whatsoever.

For instance, the chorus to 'More Than A Kiss From You' is actually relatively catchy, but the lead up to it is a complete mess. Samples and synths are thrown in randomly, the drums sound awful and the vocals just don't flow as they should, although the singing itself isn't too bad. The problem this band have is the complete identity crisis their songs convey. Without doubt they like bands such as Motion City Soundtrack or The Riverclub, but in attempting to adopt a sound such as that they've made a complete hash of it. Often simple is the best way to go, rather than overcomplicating with layers of sounds which come across as muddy. Pictures of Shanghai clearly have talent, but this demo just doesn't convey it at all well. My recommendation would be to go back to the drawing board and start again...

www.myspace.com/picturesofshanghai

Paul

starstarstarstarstar

» Want to review this record? Click here to leave your comments

Posted by Paul
2:58PM, 6th October 2005
250 Views

Tell a Friend about this item


Other Reviews For This Band:
» Stand Up and Be Proud
» POS
Options:
Reviews Index «
Back a Page «
 Subscribe to PT Mail

Menu
Releases
Reviews
Interviews
Gig Calendar
Punktastic TV
Columns
FAQ
About/Contact
Calendar

TV

Shop

Reviews
We All Need A Reason...
Valencia
6th Sep 2008, Paul
image
S/T, Radicus
Revert, Restart, Reset, Cut The...
S/T 7", Touche Amore
Rattlesnake, A Static lullaby
Strugglers, Koufax
S/T, Rosematter
Want, 3oh!3
The Silver Cord, The Classic Crime
Sweet Attention, Rookie of the Year

Gig Reviews
Milloy
Kingston Peel
6th Aug 2008, Paul
image

Interviews
You Me At 6

29th Aug 2008, Paul
image

Competitions
image

Today's Gigs
There are no gigs today!

Sponsorship Message

Content © Punktastic 2008 - Design & Scripting by Robert Bethell

PT Recordings PT Recordings News News Reviews Reviews Bands Bands Forums Forums